The Reading / Listening - Rare Books - Level 6

The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being urged to investigate AI companies for allegedly buying rare books in bulk and then destroying them. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have asked the FTC to look into claims that AI companies are digitizing the books to train their large language models (LLMs). The process includes breaking the spines of the rare works, scanning the pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of the original texts. Critics argue that such books are historically important and that it is not socially acceptable to burn them. One critic said: "The rarer a book is, the more carefully we should preserve it."

The bulk buying of books is creating a dilemma for stores that specialize in rare and antique books. They are receiving large orders for some rather valuable items, but are then questioning the ethics of destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that rare and obscure book sales have suddenly surged. Booksellers have been getting unusually large orders for out-of-print, and sometimes valuable books. It added that some books are apparently being bought not to be read, but to be digitized for AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are spending a fortune on millions of books that are being used to help train AI assistants.

Try the same news story at these easier levels:

    Rare Books - Level 4  or  Rare Books - Level 5

Sources
  • https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ftc-ai-companies-destroying-books/
  • https://www.wsj.com/articles/ais-need-for-content-has-put-rare-book-dealers-in-a-bind-1ac5a053
  • https://novaramedia.com/2026/08/21/hidden-airtag-exposes-amazon-destroying-rare-books-in-bulk-to-train-ai/


Make sure you try all of the online activities for this reading and listening - There are dictations, multiple choice activities, drag and drop activities, sentence jumbles, which word activities, text reconstructions, spelling, gap fills and a whole lot more. Please enjoy :-)

Warm-ups

1. BOOKS: Students walk around the class and talk to other students about books. Change partners often and share your findings.
2. CHAT: In pairs / groups, talk about these topics or words from the article. What will the article say about them? What can you say about these words and your life?
       investigate / AI companies / rare books / large language models / pages / critics / rare
       bulk buying / dilemma / antique / ethics / obscure / spending a fortune / AI assistants
Have a chat about the topics you liked. Change topics and partners frequently.
3. UNLAWFUL: Students A strongly believe it should be unlawful to destroy rare books; Students B strongly believe that's silly. Change partners again and talk about your conversations.
4. ANTIQUES: What do you think of these antique things? How important are they? Complete this table with your partner(s). Change partners often and share what you wrote.


Antiques

What I Think

Preservation

Books

 

 

Porcelain figures

 

 

Clocks

 

 

Writing desks

 

 

Rings

 

 

Maps

 

 

MY e-BOOK
ESL resource book with copiable worksheets and handouts - 1,000 Ideas and Activities for Language Teachers / English teachers
See a sample

5. RARE: Spend one minute writing down all of the different words you associate with the word "rare". Share your words with your partner(s) and talk about them. Together, put the words into different categories.
6. BOOK GENRES: Rank these with your partner. Put the best book genres at the top. Change partners often and share your rankings.

  • Fantasy
  • Philosophy
  • Romance
  • Self-help
  • Science fiction
  • Horror
  • Comedy
  • Biography

 

Vocabulary

    Paragraph 1

      1. urged a. To keep something safe and in good condition.
      2. allegedly b. Statements that something is true.
      3. claims (noun) c. The part of a book that holds the pages together.
      4. in bulk d. Asked someone strongly to do something.
      5. spine e. Good or right enough for people to agree to or be OK with.
      6. acceptable f. Said to be true, but not yet proved.
      7. preserve g. In large amounts.

    Paragraph 2

      8. dilemma h. Not well known or not easy to find.
      9. specialize i. To work mainly in one particular area or subject.
      10. ethics j. A very large amount of money.
      11. obscure (adjective) k. A difficult situation where you have to choose between two things.
      12. surged l. Increased very quickly and by a large amount.
      13. apparently m. Ideas about what is right and wrong.
      14. a fortune n. As far as you know or can see, but not certainly.

 

Before reading / listening

1. TRUE / FALSE: Read the headline. Guess if 1-8 below are true (T) or false (F).

  1. The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being investigated.     T / F
  2. It is alleged AI companies are breaking the spines of rare books.     T / F
  3. Critics said it was socially acceptable to burn books.     T / F
  4. One critic said we should preserve all books.     T / F
  5. Rare and antique book stores have a dilemma over selling the rare books. T / F
  6. Some bookstores are questioning the morality of destroying rare books.  T / F
  7. The article says book stores are reprinting out-of-print books.     T / F
  8. A newspaper said AI companies are spending a fortune on books.     T / F

2. SYNONYM MATCH: Match the following synonyms from the article.

  1. urged
  2. allegedly
  3. claims
  4. obscure
  5. preserve
  6. dilemma
  7. ethics
  8. surged
  9. apparently
  10. a fortune
  1. awkward situation
  2. assertions
  3. seemingly
  4. look after
  5. morals
  6. encouraged
  7. a huge amount
  8. reportedly
  9. suddenly increased
  10. little known

3. PHRASE MATCH: (Sometimes more than one choice is possible.)

  1. investigate AI companies for allegedly
  2. The process includes breaking the
  3. among the last surviving copies
  4. such books are historically
  5. it is not socially acceptable
  6. bulk buying of books is creating a
  7. specialize in rare
  8. obscure book sales
  9. companies are spending
  10. used to help
  1. spines of the rare works
  2. and antique books
  3. to burn them
  4. a fortune
  5. dilemma
  6. buying rare books
  7. of the original texts
  8. train AI assistants
  9. important
  10. have suddenly surged

Gap fill

Put these words into the spaces in the paragraph below.
historically
claims
rarer
urged
surviving
socially
allegedly
spines

The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being (1) _________________________________ to investigate AI companies for (2) _________________________________ buying rare books in bulk and then destroying them. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have asked the FTC to look into (3) _________________________________ that AI companies are digitizing the books to train their large language models (LLMs). The process includes breaking the (4) _________________________________ of the rare works, scanning the pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be among the last (5) _________________________________ copies of the original texts. Critics argue that such books are (6) _________________________________ important and that it is not (7) _________________________________ acceptable to burn them. One critic said: "The (8) _________________________________ a book is, the more carefully we should preserve it."

Put these words into the spaces in the paragraph below.
obscure
train
apparently
bulk
fortune
questioning
rather
unusually

The (9) _________________________________ buying of books is creating a dilemma for stores that specialize in rare and antique books. They are receiving large orders for some (10) _________________________________ valuable items, but are then (11) _________________________________ the ethics of destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that rare and (12) _________________________________ book sales have suddenly surged. Booksellers have been getting (13) _________________________________ large orders for out-of-print, and sometimes valuable books. It added that some books are (14) _________________________________ being bought not to be read, but to be digitized for AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are spending a (15) _________________________________ on millions of books that are being used to help (16) _________________________________ AI assistants.

Listening — Guess the answers. Listen to check.

1)  being urged to investigate AI companies for allegedly buying rare ______
     a.  books on bulk
     b.  books in bulk
     c.  books in book
     d.  books on balk
2)  AI companies are digitizing the books to train their ______
     a.  large languages models
     b.  largeness language models
     c.  at large language models
     d.  large language models
3)  Some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of ______
     a.  the original texts
     b.  the originally texts
     c.  the originals texts
     d.  them original texts
4)  such books are historically important and that it is not socially acceptable ______
     a.  to burn them
     b.  to born them
     c.  to bourn them
     d.  to barn them
5)  The rarer a book is, the more carefully we ______
     a.  should preserve them
     b.  should preserve it
     c.  should preserve that
     d.  should persevere it

6)  The bulk buying of books is creating a ______
     a.  dilemma for stores
     b.  drama for stores
     c.  diuretic for stores
     d.  diorama for stores
7)  large orders for some rather valuable items, but are then ______
     a.  question in the ethics
     b.  questioning a ethics
     c.  questioning them ethics
     d.  questioning the ethics
8)  Booksellers have been getting unusually large orders for ______
     a.  out-of-print
     b.  out-off-print
     c.  out-oft-print
     d.  outer print
9)  It added that some books are apparently being bought not ______
     a.  to been read
     b.  to be red
     c.  to be read
     d.  to be a read
10)  Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are ______
     a.  spending a fortunes
     b.  spend in a fortune
     c.  spending a fortunate
     d.  spending a fortune

Listening — Listen and fill in the gaps

The Federal Trade Commission in the USA (1) _______________________________________________ to investigate AI companies (2) _______________________________________________ rare books in bulk and then destroying them. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have asked the FTC to look (3) _______________________________________________ AI companies are digitizing the books to train their large language models (LLMs). The process includes (4) _______________________________________________ of the rare works, scanning the pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of the original texts. Critics argue that such (5) _______________________________________________ important and that it is not socially acceptable to burn them. One critic said: "The rarer a book is, the more carefully we (6) _______________________________________________."

The bulk buying of books is creating (7) _______________________________________________ stores that specialize in rare and antique books. They are receiving large orders for some (8) _______________________________________________, but are then questioning the ethics of destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that (9) _______________________________________________ book sales have suddenly surged. Booksellers have been getting unusually large (10) _______________________________________________, and sometimes valuable books. It added that some books are (11) _______________________________________________ not to be read, but to be digitized for AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are (12) _______________________________________________ on millions of books that are being used to help train AI assistants.

Comprehension questions

  1. What is being asked to investigate AI companies?
  2. What does the article say AI companies are using books to train?
  3. What are AI companies breaking?
  4. What do some critics believe it is unacceptable to do to rare books?
  5. What did a critic say we should do with rarer books?
  6. What is bulk book buying creating for rare book sellers?
  7. What are booksellers questioning?
  8. What does a newspaper say has surged?
  9. What did the newspaper say books are being digitized for?
  10. How much money are AI companies spending on books?

Multiple choice quiz

1)  What is being asked to investigate AI companies?
a) the internet
b) the Federal Trade Commission
c) a book company
d) a court
2)  What does the article say AI companies are using books to train?
a) the internet
b) writers and journalists
c) employees
d) large language models
3) What are AI companies breaking?
a) book spines
b) sales records
c) bandwidth limits
d) the rules
4) What do some critics believe it is unacceptable to do to rare books?
a) write in them
b) scan them
c) burn them
d) trash them
5) What did a critic say we should do with rarer books?
a) auction them
b) preserve them
c) give them to children
d) put them in museums

6) What is bulk book buying creating for rare book sellers?
a) a dilemma
b) opportunities
c) huge profits
d) a headache
7) What are booksellers questioning?
a) themselves
b) AI companies
c) the ethics of destroying books
d) companies who destroy books
8) What does a newspaper say has surged?
a) rare book sales
b) demand for paperbacks
c) the popularity of novels
d) an interest in hardbacks
9) What did the newspaper say books are being digitized for?
a) AI training
b) the better good
c) schools and universities
d) posterity
10) How much money are AI companies spending on books?
a) about $10 million
b) gazillions of dollars
c) a surprisingly small amount
d) a fortune

Role play

Role  A – Fantasy
You think fantasy is the best book genre. Tell the others three reasons why. Tell them what is wrong with their genres. Also, tell the others which is the least interesting of these (and why): philosophy, biography or self-help.

Role  B – Philosophy
You think philosophy is the best book genre. Tell the others three reasons why. Tell them what is wrong with their genres. Also, tell the others which is the least interesting of these (and why): fantasy, biography or self-help.

Role  C – Biography
You think biography is the best book genre. Tell the others three reasons why. Tell them what is wrong with their genres. Also, tell the others which is the least interesting of these (and why): philosophy, fantasy or self-help.

Role  D – Self-help
You think self-help is the best book genre. Tell the others three reasons why. Tell them what is wrong with their genres. Also, tell the others which is the least interesting of these (and why): philosophy, biography or fantasy.

After reading / listening

1. WORD SEARCH: Look in your dictionary / computer to find collocates, other meanings, information, synonyms … for the words...

'books'

  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • and 'AI'.

  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • ________________
  • • Share your findings with your partners.

    • Make questions using the words you found.

    • Ask your partner / group your questions.

    2. ARTICLE QUESTIONS: Look back at the article and write down some questions you would like to ask the class about the text.

    •Share your questions with other classmates / groups. •Ask your partner / group your questions.

    3. GAP FILL: In pairs / groups, compare your answers to this exercise. Check your answers. Talk about the words from the activity. Were they new, interesting, worth learning…?

    4. VOCABULARY: Circle any words you do not understand. In groups, pool unknown words and use dictionaries to find their meanings.

    5. TEST EACH OTHER: Look at the words below. With your partner, try to recall how they were used in the text:

    • urged
    • claims
    • process
    • pages
    • last
    • carefully
    • dilemma
    • orders
    • ethics
    • sales
    • apparently
    • fortune

    Student survey

    Write five GOOD questions about this topic in the table. Do this in pairs. Each student must write the questions on his / her own paper. When you have finished, interview other students. Write down their answers.

    (Please look at page 12 of the PDF to see a photocopiable example of this activity.)

    Discussion - Rare Books

    STUDENT A’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student B)

    1. What did you think when you read the headline?
    2. What images are in your mind when you hear the word 'book'?
    3. What do you think of books?
    4. Do you prefer reading paper books or digital books?
    5. What's the oldest book you own?
    6. Should there be laws about bulk buying rare books?
    7. What do you think of the smell of books?
    8. How do you feel when you are in a library?
    9. How do you feel about rare books being destroyed?
    10. Are AI companies too big and powerful?

    STUDENT B’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student A)

    1. Did you like reading this article? Why/not?
    2. What do you think of when you hear the term AI?
    3. What do you think about what you read?
    4. What are the ethics of destroying books?
    5. What are your favourite books?
    6. Why do AI companies need to scan old books?
    7. How do you feel when you are in a bookstore?
    8. What should companies do after scanning the books?
    9. How useful are AI assistants to you?
    10. What questions would you like to ask AI company bosses?

    Discussion — Write your own questions

    STUDENT A’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student B)

    (a) ________________

    (b) ________________

    (c) ________________

    (d) ________________

    (e) ________________

    STUDENT B’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student A)

    (f) ________________

    (g) ________________

    (h) ________________

    (i) ________________

    (j) ________________

    Language — Cloze (Gap-fill)

    The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being (1) ____ to investigate AI companies for allegedly buying rare books (2) ____ bulk and then destroying them. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have asked the FTC to look into (3) ____ that AI companies are digitizing the books to train their large language models (LLMs). The process includes breaking the (4) ____ of the rare works, scanning the pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of the original texts. Critics (5) ____ that such books are historically important and that it is not socially acceptable to burn them. One critic said: "The (6) ____ a book is, the more carefully we should preserve it."

    The bulk buying of books is creating a (7) ____ for stores that specialize in rare and antique books. They are receiving large orders for some (8) ____ valuable items, but are then questioning the ethics of destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that rare and obscure book sales have suddenly surged. Booksellers have been getting (9) ____ large orders for obscure, out-of-print, and sometimes valuable books. It added that some books are apparently (10) ____ bought not to be read, but to be digitized (11) ____ AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are spending a (12) ____ on millions of books that are being used to help train AI assistants.

    Which of these words go in the above text?

    1. (a)     purged     (b)     splurged     (c)     surged     (d)     urged    
    2. (a)     to     (b)     by     (c)     on     (d)     in    
    3. (a)     claimants     (b)     claims     (c)     claimers     (d)     claiming    
    4. (a)     bones     (b)     vertebrae     (c)     spines     (d)     columns    
    5. (a)     arguing     (b)     argument     (c)     argue     (d)     argues    
    6. (a)     rarer     (b)     rarity     (c)     rare     (d)     rarely    
    7. (a)     diagonal     (b)     dilemma     (c)     diameter     (d)     division    
    8. (a)     rather     (b)     lather     (c)     bather     (d)     father    
    9. (a)     usual     (b)     unusually     (c)     unusual     (d)     usually    
    10. (a)     been     (b)     be     (c)     being     (d)     are    
    11. (a)     at     (b)     of     (c)     for     (d)     and    
    12. (a)     bonanza     (b)     wealth     (c)     lottery     (d)     fortune

    Spelling

    Paragraph 1

    1. Federal Trade mCmsoisnio
    2. being urged to ntteegiaivs AI companies
    3. lglelydea buying rare books in bulk
    4. breaking the sipens of the rare works
    5. not socially bctaeplcae
    6. the more carefully we should revprsee it

    Paragraph 2

    1. creating a mldamie
    2. rare and taineuq books
    3. orders for some rather uelablva items
    4. rare and oercsub book sales
    5. books are penatlrayp being bought
    6. companies are spending a nfetrou

    Put the text back together

    (    )   acceptable to burn them. One critic said: "The rarer a book is, the more carefully we should preserve it."
    (    )   antique books. They are receiving large orders for some rather valuable items, but are then questioning the ethics
    (    )   asked the FTC to look into claims that AI companies are digitizing the books to train their large language
    (    )   models (LLMs). The process includes breaking the spines of the rare works, scanning the
    (    )   of destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that rare and obscure book sales have suddenly
    (    )   pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of the original
    (    )   print, and sometimes valuable books. It added that some books are apparently being bought not to be
    (    )   rare books in bulk and then destroying them. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have
    (    )   read, but to be digitized for AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are
    (    )   spending a fortune on millions of books that are being used to help train AI assistants.
    (    )   surged. Booksellers have been getting unusually large orders for out-of-
    (    )   texts. Critics argue that such books are historically important and that it is not socially
    (    )   The bulk buying of books is creating a dilemma for stores that specialize in rare and
    (  1  )   The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being urged to investigate AI companies for allegedly buying

    Put the words in the right order

    1. AI   allegedly   books   buying   companies   for   investigate   rare   .
    2. AI   are   Claims   companies   digitizing   books   the   that   .
    3. breaking   includes   of   process   rare   spines   The   works   .
    4. copies   last   of   original   surviving   texts   The   the   .
    5. argue   books   Critics   historically   important   such   are   that   .
    6. a   books   Bulk   creating   dilemma   buying   is   of   .
    7. for   items   large   orders   Receiving   rather   some   valuable   .
    8. and   book   have   obscure   Rare   sales   suddenly   surged   .
    9. a   are   books   Companies   fortune   on   spending   .
    10. AI   being   books   help   assistants   to   train   used   .

    Circle the correct word (20 pairs)

    The Federal Trade Commission in the USA is being surged / urged to investigate AI companies for allegedly bought / buying rare books in bulk and then destroying them / it. Groups like the Consumer Federation of America have asked the FTC to look into clams / claims that AI companies are digitizing the books to train / workout their large language models (LLMs). The process includes breaking the spines of the rare works, scanning the pages, and then destroying them. Some destroyed books may be other / among the last / lost surviving copies of the originally / original texts. Critics argue that such books are historically important and that it is not socially acceptable to / for burn them. One critic said: "The rarer a book is, the more carefully we should reserve / preserve it."

    The bulk buying by / of books is creating a dilemma for stores that specialize in rare / rarity and antique books. They are receiving large orders for some rather valuable items / item, but are then questioning the ethics of / on destroying books. The Wall Street Journal reported that rare and obscure book sales have suddenly urged / surged. Booksellers have been getting unusually large orders for / to out-of-print, and sometimes valuable books. It increased / added that some books are apparently being bought / buying not to be read, but to be digitized for AI training. Earlier this year, the Washington Post reported that the companies are spent / spending a fortune on millions of books that are being used for / to help train AI assistants.

    Talk about the connection between each pair of words in italics, and why the correct word is correct. Look up the definition of new words.

    Insert the vowels (a, e, i, o, u)

    Th_  F_d_r_l  Tr_d_  C_mm_ss__n  _n  th_  _S_  _s  b__ng  _rg_d  t_  _nv_st_g_t_  __  c_mp_n__s  f_r  _ll_g_dly  b_y_ng  r_r_  b__ks  _n  b_lk  _nd  th_n  d_str_y_ng  th_m.  Gr__ps  l_k_  th_  C_ns_m_r  F_d_r_t__n  _f  _m_r_c_  h_v_  _sk_d  th_  FTC  t_  l__k  _nt_  cl__ms  th_t  __  c_mp_n__s  _r_  d_g_t_z_ng  th_  b__ks  t_  tr__n  th__r  l_rg_  l_ng__g_  m_d_ls  (LLMs).  Th_  pr_c_ss  _ncl_d_s  br__k_ng  th_  sp_n_s  _f  th_  r_r_  w_rks,  sc_nn_ng  th_  p_g_s,  _nd  th_n  d_str_y_ng  th_m.  S_m_  d_str_y_d  b__ks  m_y  b_  _m_ng  th_  l_st  s_rv_v_ng  c_p__s  _f  th_  _r_g_n_l  t_xts.  Cr_t_cs  _rg__  th_t  s_ch  b__ks  _r_  h_st_r_c_lly  _mp_rt_nt  _nd  th_t  _t  _s  n_t  s_c__lly  _cc_pt_bl_  t_  b_rn  th_m.  _n_  cr_t_c  s__d:  "Th_  r_r_r  _  b__k  _s,  th_  m_r_  c_r_f_lly  w_  sh__ld  pr_s_rv_  _t."

    Th_  b_lk  b_y_ng  _f  b__ks  _s  cr__t_ng  _  d_l_mm_  f_r  st_r_s  th_t  sp_c__l_z_  _n  r_r_  _nd  _nt_q__  b__ks.  Th_y  _r_  r_c__v_ng  l_rg_  _rd_rs  f_r  s_m_  r_th_r  v_l__bl_  _t_ms,  b_t  _r_  th_n  q__st__n_ng  th_  _th_cs  _f  d_str_y_ng  b__ks.  Th_  W_ll  Str__t  J__rn_l  r_p_rt_d  th_t  r_r_  _nd  _bsc_r_  b__k  s_l_s  h_v_  s_dd_nly  s_rg_d.  B__ks_ll_rs  h_v_  b__n  g_tt_ng  _n_s__lly  l_rg_  _rd_rs  f_r  __t-_f-pr_nt,  _nd  s_m_t_m_s  v_l__bl_  b__ks.  _t  _dd_d  th_t  s_m_  b__ks  _r_  _pp_r_ntly  b__ng  b__ght  n_t  t_  b_  r__d,  b_t  t_  b_  d_g_t_z_d  f_r  __  tr__n_ng.  __rl__r  th_s  y__r,  th_  W_sh_ngt_n  P_st  r_p_rt_d  th_t  th_  c_mp_n__s  _r_  sp_nd_ng  _  f_rt_n_  _n  m_ll__ns  _f  b__ks  th_t  _r_  b__ng  _s_d  t_  h_lp  tr__n  __  _ss_st_nts.

    Punctuate the text and add capitals

    the federal trade commission in the usa is being urged to investigate ai companies for allegedly buying rare books in bulk and then destroying them groups like the consumer federation of america have asked the ftc to look into claims that ai companies are digitizing the books to train their large language models llms the process includes breaking the spines of the rare works scanning the pages and then destroying them some destroyed books may be among the last surviving copies of the original texts critics argue that such books are historically important and that it is not socially acceptable to burn them one critic said the rarer a book is the more carefully we should preserve it

    the bulk buying of books is creating a dilemma for stores that specialize in rare and antique books they are receiving large orders for some rather valuable items but are then questioning the ethics of destroying books the wall street journal reported that rare and obscure book sales have suddenly surged booksellers have been getting unusually large orders for out of print and sometimes valuable books it added that some books are apparently being bought not to be read but to be digitized for ai training earlier this year the washington post reported that the companies are spending a fortune on millions of books that are being used to help train ai assistants

    Put a slash (/) where the spaces are

    TheFederalTradeCommissionintheUSAisbeingurgedtoinvestigateAI
    companiesforallegedlybuyingrarebooksinbulkandthendestroyingth
    em.GroupsliketheConsumerFederationofAmericahaveaskedtheFTC
    tolookintoclaimsthatAIcompaniesaredigitizingthebookstotraintheirl
    argelanguagemodels(LLMs).Theprocessincludesbreakingthespines
    oftherareworks,scanningthepages,andthendestroyingthem.Somed
    estroyedbooksmaybeamongthelastsurvivingcopiesoftheoriginaltex
    ts.Criticsarguethatsuchbooksarehistoricallyimportantandthatitisno
    tsociallyacceptabletoburnthem.Onecriticsaid:"Therarerabookis,the
    morecarefullyweshouldpreserveit."Thebulkbuyingofbooksiscreatin
    gadilemmaforstoresthatspecializeinrareandantiquebooks.Theyarer
    eceivinglargeordersforsomerathervaluableitems,butarethenquesti
    oningtheethicsofdestroyingbooks.TheWallStreetJournalreportedth
    atrareandobscurebooksaleshavesuddenlysurged.Booksellershaveb
    eengettingunusuallylargeordersforout-of-print,andsometimesvalu
    ablebooks.Itaddedthatsomebooksareapparentlybeingboughtnotto
    beread,buttobedigitizedforAItraining.Earlierthisyear,theWashingto
    nPostreportedthatthecompaniesarespendingafortuneonmillionsofb
    ooksthatarebeingusedtohelptrainAIassistants.

    Free writing

    Write about the lesson page for 10 minutes. Comment on your partner’s paper.

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

     

    Academic writing

    Old books should never be destroyed. Discuss.

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    _____________________________________________________________________________

     

    Homework

    1. VOCABULARY EXTENSION: Choose several of the words from the text. Use a dictionary or Google’s search field (or another search engine) to build up more associations / collocations of each word.
    2. INTERNET: Search the Internet and find out more about this news story. Share what you discover with your partner(s) in the next lesson.
    3. BOOKS: Make a poster about books. Show your work to your classmates in the next lesson. Did you all have similar things?
    4. SCHOOL LIBRARIES: Write a magazine article about all old books being kept in school libraries. Include imaginary interviews with people who are for and against this.
    Read what you wrote to your classmates in the next lesson. Write down any new words and expressions you hear from your partner(s).
    5. WHAT HAPPENED NEXT? Write a newspaper article about the next stage in this news story. Read what you wrote to your classmates in the next lesson. Give each other feedback on your articles.
    6. LETTER: Write a letter to an expert on books. Ask him/her three questions about them. Give him/her three of your ideas on what we should do with antique books. Read your letter to your partner(s) in your next lesson. Your partner(s) will answer your questions.

    A Few Additional Activities for Students

    Ask your students what they have read, seen or heard about this news in their own language. Students are likely to / may have have encountered this news in their L1 and therefore bring a background knowledge to the classroom.

    Get students to role play different characters from this news story.

    Ask students to keep track of this news and revisit it to discuss in your next class.

    Ask students to male predictions of how this news might develop in the next few days or weeks, and then revisit and discuss in a future class.

    Ask students to write a follow-up story to this news.

    Students role play a journalist and someone who witnessed or was a part of this news. Perhaps they could make a video of the interview.

    Ask students to keep a news journal in English and add this story to their thoughts.

    Also...

    Buy my 1,000 Ideas and Activities for Language Teachers eBook. It has hundreds of ideas, activity templates, reproducible activities for:

    • News
    • Warm ups
    • Pre-reading / Post-reading
    • Using headlines
    • Working with words
    • While-reading / While-listening
    • Moving from text to speech
    • Post-reading / Post-listening
    • Discussions
    • Using opinions
    • Plans
    • Language
    • Using lists
    • Using quotes
    • Task-based activities
    • Role plays
    • Using the central characters in the article
    • Using themes from the news
    • Homework

    Buy my book

    $US 9.99

    Answers

    (Please look at page 26 of the PDF to see a photocopiable example of this activity.)

    Help Support This Web Site

    • Please consider helping Breaking News English.com

    Sean Banville's Book

    Thank You